Government announce ban on plastic straws – is an alternative necessary?

Images shared of plastic straws and cotton buds floating in the sea next to jellyfish and turtles have had a powerful effect on many who have seen them over the last year.

Not only have plastic straws become unpopular with many individuals, the government have also started to take notice. This week the UK Government have published their draft legislation banning plastic straws, plastic stirrers and cotton buds as of April 2020.

Although the sale of these items will still be permitted within certain industries, these single use plastic items will only be allowed for use where medically needed. A huge step in the right direction.

The reason this environmentally friendly legislation has been passed successfully? – The consultation process had such strong public support with over 80% of the public agreeing with the ban and the majority of the remaining 20% stating they should only be allowed where medically needed. The result shows that the opinions of the masses really can make a difference.

Although there was an overwhelming response to ban these plastic items, over half the respondents within the consultation groups were unsure of the alternatives. If we get rid of one product and just replace it with something else, we need to understand the impacts. Otherwise we could end up just swapping one environmental problem for another.

So… what are the alternatives?

Well the best thing for the environment is to not use straws or cotton buds at all (unless needed for medical reasons). Reducing waste is the simplest thing we can do to protect this world – saving energy, materials, transport and landfill room (or more energy and transport to recycle).

Cotton buds

Did you know that using cotton buds in your ears actually stimulates the production of more wax than you had to start with! Plus they are one of the most common reasons for ear infections, build up of wax and blocked ears. So by not using them you will be both benefitting your health and the environment. If you are adamant you want to use them then opt for wooden or or paper based sticks and compost them where you can.


Due to popularity many pubs and restaurants have already switched to paper straws in favour of plastic. But are these actually any better?

The simple answer is yes, but only slightly because they biodegrade a lot quicker. They are still a wasteful single use item, using trees and energy to make something you use for a few minutes before throwing away.

The other options becoming more readily available include bamboo or metal straws. Out of the two, bamboo is more environmentally friendly in its production and if looked after can last a couple of years. Metal have a bigger impact in production but could last a lifetime, so it depends if you are a long term straw drinker willing to look after this product (and you are someone who will remember to take it with you to use!)

Metal straws are an alternative for people not willing to give them up altogether. If you want to invest, then support local shops and buy a product you will use and look after for years such as this set from Wild Iris, Ironbridge.

Overall do we really need any straws? What’s wrong with simply enjoying your drink from a glass as we have done for many years.

Cutting out single use plastic is a huge step in the right direction, but cutting out single use anything is even better whatever material it is made from.

Do you have bamboo or metal straws? If so what are your thoughts. Are they as good as the marketing machines make out?

2 thoughts on “Government announce ban on plastic straws – is an alternative necessary?

Add yours

  1. Great first step, but what about the rest of the plastic? These people who care about the straws then don’t see when they buy most products that it’s all plastic and everything around us is plastic, and that we are drowning in plastic. Yet a little straw is their main concern. Open your eyes and wake up to the plastic mess that our consumption habits have bestowed upon us! This is one step, but this step only takes you so far.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Agreed, but every step in the right direction is better than standing still. Sometimes a specific thing is needed to highlight an issue and at least it gets people talking 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: